Return to Main Discussion Page

Discussion

Main Menu | Search Discussions

Search Discussions

 
 

Jeffrey Campbell

1 Year Ago

Women In Combat

Spent the evening at the fights, and this got me wondering. How do you feel about women in sanctioned sports where their bodies are subjected to physical force? Personally, I see it as no different as men's contact sports, as physical injuries are all part of it. Though, some may have a different opinion.

Mixed Martial Arts is certainly a much different sport than boxing, and I feel as long as the Athletics Commissions sanction everything there should be no issues.

Thoughts?

Photobucket

Reply Order

Post Reply
 

Johnny Trippick

1 Year Ago

Jeffrey!

Not sure. I get a little uneasy about women fighting. Don't think it's merely a cultural thing - more atavistic than that.

 

Richard Rizzo

1 Year Ago

As long as it's mud wrestling. :)

 

Roseann Caputo

1 Year Ago

If women wish to do it, I say let them. It's their choice.

Richard - LOL

 

I do fun boxing and semi serious MMA I also do weights (hence the huge operation this year) and am now getting back into that after time off repairing. One of the kick boxing champs walks her dog on the field outside my house and we often chat about the sport. She is retiring soon but wants a last match in Thailand.

I am a girly-girl but also like the physical power in these sports. It is also great if someone tries to attack me again. I have lost that fear :)

 

Andrew Pacheco

1 Year Ago

Like most everything else in life, I think it's all good.

That being said...as a fan, I think women's MMA and kickboxing are much more enjoyable to watch than women's boxing. Women just don't punch like men. It's just the way we're built different. I'd rather see women compete in a combat sport with tools they can use more effectively than punching alone.

 

Marlene Burns

1 Year Ago

and now for a commercial break ( from my daughter's family)
http://www.phillymma.com/

 

Mike Jeffries

1 Year Ago

If this is considered a spectator sport in some quarters it is a sad reflection on the way society is heading. Useful for keeping fit and for self defence I agree but not as a form of entertainment that any man with the slightest respect for the gentle sex would want to watch.

 

Jeffrey Campbell

1 Year Ago

Mike,

Thanks for your inputs. You would be surprised how much attention the sport is getting, it's growing bigger than ever here in the States.

 

Elizabeth Lane

1 Year Ago

Some women like the rough and tumble sports. Personally, I would use Martial arts for self-defense, although Mr. Smith and Wesson I understand is very effective.
There is a rising number of women as well as men, applying for Concealed Weapon licenses.
But back to the original question: I think it is the times we live in as the lines between gender-roles becomes more blurred. When I was in school there were not as many girls sports besides track and tennis.....now there is soccer, basketball, baseball and in some areas girls are wanting to be allowed to play on all-male football teams. There are also all-girl's rodeos.......Look at the Olympics, women compete in virtually all the sports, and as in the case of equestrian sports they are allowed to compete with men.
Women are evolving into the less vulnerable, out of choice or out of life-circumstances.

 

Lynn Palmer

1 Year Ago

I'm always a little edgy about society dictating what is "appropriate" or "lady-like". I worked my way up to a brown belt in judo back in the day. It was only one aspect of my life -- I still enjoyed dressing up, wearing heels, cooking, etc. It turns out that life doesn't cut a person any breaks because of their gender. The skills, both mental and physical, that I learned then have served me well since. I'm glad I had the opportunity to test myself in a very physical and competitive environment.

 

Jeffrey Campbell

1 Year Ago

Great points, both Elizabeth and Lynn.

Times HAVE changed and women are getting more an more opportunities with their athletic abilities. I do not think professional football (for example) is ready for a women's league, and this is probably due to the physical nature of the sport. Time will tell, though.

 

Paul Cowan

1 Year Ago

I'd rather see women kicking a ball around than kicking each other about. I think men have an inbuilt desire to protect women from harm, so I find the idea of enjoying watching them trying to harm each other bizarre. Come to that, I don't enjoy watching men trying to inflict brain damage on each other in a boxing ring, either.
Keeping fit and learning self-defence is quite different.

 

Mike Jeffries

1 Year Ago

Jeffery, I'm not surprised in the least by the fact that this "sport" is growing in the States, and probably here as well, merely saddened by it.

Lately like millions of others I watched with great pleasure the Olympics and and the amazing performances put up by women, especially British women ( I am as partisan as the next man) and am in awe of the dedication and hard work that is required to achieve this however so called combat sports between women as a SPECTACLE I find rather seedy, and like Paul have never really been happy about watching men boxing.

During training in my time in the Forces we all had to take our turn in the Ring and that's fine and although I admire any man who chooses boxing as a profession he takes a terrible risk to his long term health for every punch he takes day in, day out. It's in our nature as men to fight but somehow I just can't accept that women have that unhappy tendency to anything like the same degree.

Anyway I've always thought that a woman has more of an inbuilt ability to hurt with a few well chosen words rather than a punch on the nose!

 

Roseann Caputo

1 Year Ago

I've never been big in to boxing either, but if you look at it from a science/nature perspective, inherently, we are very aggressive creatures. Come between a mother and her young and see how well that works out for you.

Mike/Paul - Ah, you're old school gents. I think that it's sweet in today's world. :-)

 

Minnie Lippiatt

1 Year Ago

All I know is I wouldn't want to be in a fight with anyone especially women.

 

Mario Donk

1 Year Ago

I don't get it, be it male or female fighting, as I consider a fight life threatening I will try to be the only one that walks away, if I can walk away before the fight I will. To me a fight is not a show of strength but a total breakdown in communications and then I consider it life threatening, As suck I am not into pretend fights, Your the only one left standing or your dead.

 

verbal fighting between men, women, or mixed is sometimes far more dangerous than trained fighting between two equals

Trained fighting is an excellent thing of beauty, skill and motivation.

 

Jeffrey Campbell

1 Year Ago

Well said, Beth!

 

Daniel Rauch

1 Year Ago

I'm a big fan of combat sports, there is great honor from my perspective if challenging your self through combat, there is a lot one can learn about themselves through contests like these.


as for girls participation, I approve! in fact I rather enjoy watching female MMA contests, not for the sexuality but the difference in ferocity that they seem to bring to a contest, quite entertaining and quite commendable competitors to say the least.

 

Peter Piatt

1 Year Ago

Not much into watching any type of sport myself, but women take on more than combat sports today.

Sell Art Online

 

Johnny Trippick

1 Year Ago

The beauty of the perfect punch is in the eye of the beholder.

 

Kevin Callahan

1 Year Ago

Way back in 1974 I was stationed in New Port, RI the US Navy Officer's candidate School. Impromptu sports were a part of our training experience. As a former football player I relished the ball field. One of our officer in training companions was a young woman from my native state of Iowa. She was busy on the track filed whomping on any and all comers. The men were incredulous that she was so athletic. I pointed out to them that the state of Iowa encouraged their young women to participate in track, softball, and basketball. At the time Iowa had many of the top female basketball players in the country. Most of these "old Boy" officer candidates were from south of the Mason-Dixon and just looked at me like I had lost my marbles. But none challenged the "girl" to a race.

It is a fitting tribute to how far we have come that we forget about how little our women were encouraged and allowed to participate in our society. Not merely the brutishness of contact sports or combat but as serious news people, CEOs, actress being something other than a bimbo, and politics.

Anyone who thinks we should "go back" should read a bit about how women and working class people were treated around the world just prior to WWI. Thank goodness today we find that thought shocking.

 

John Crothers

1 Year Ago

That being said...as a fan, I think women's MMA and kickboxing are much more enjoyable to watch than women's boxing. Women just don't punch like men

For the most part you are probably right. But I think Ali's daughter could knock out a hell of a lot of men!

 

Gary Whitton

1 Year Ago

I'm all for women learning how to defend themselves. But these folks that want to turn fighting into a hobby or profession, well, just like a football player, a boxer, etc, if they choose to do it, they get what comes with it. Don't think if Mohammed Ali had a choice, he'd want get Parkinson's, but would he have done things different, not sure.

 

Mike Jeffries

1 Year Ago

Here in England we are no strangers to women participating in our society as illustrated by our past when the greatest leaps in our history happened to coincide with a female monarch on the throne namely the first Elizabethan and the Victorian ages. Both these women held great power but in their wisdom left the fighting to the men who by their nature are more suited to that role. Perhaps it is time for a female President in the Land of the Free to polish the rough edge of American society a little and in the tradition of the old school treat a female like a lady first and for men to strive to be their equals.

I fail to see that the spectacle of two women engaged in a combat sport is progress by any criteria, in fact I would go so far to say it is a backward step for women in general, undignified and demeaning if it is viewed as a spectator sport. As good exercise for keeping fit it has its place in the privacy of the gym but no more than that.

It all smacks a little of bear-baiting, cock fighting and the bullring to me in that it panders to the baser instincts of male voyeurism and I still cannot understand why any man with any respect for women would want to watch such contests.

 

Or, it is a sports lover, watching a sport, which just happens to be women who want to fight, instead of men who want to fight.

It is up to the women who want to fight if they do or not and, to call them less than feminine, may just get you a bop on the nose

 

Loretta Luglio

1 Year Ago

From a practical standpoint I think martial arts should be taught to all girls as part of their gym curriculum. I believe Hawaii does this or has in the past. It is an excellent means of self protection that doesn't rely on just brute upper body strength. I can't say I enjoy viewing it for sort (males and females) but for girls in particular it should be encouraged.

 

Mario Donk

1 Year Ago

Beth I totally disagree. Fighting should be beautiful in its movements if you hope to win, but fighting for any other reason then to protect your own life is abusive, if not to yourself then the other person. I do not see it as a sport regardless that many do. Learning to fight is good as its to protect yourself but fighting is not a sport, its what one does in war and if you loose your dead, nothing beautiful about it, nether is the mind set to engage in a fight as clearly there is something wrong with the individual that seeks to improve his own standing by kicking the crap out of another regardless how elegantly he moves. No, Words are not more dangerous, a civilized person uses words to avoid a fight. Do you wish to change the saying sticks and stones will break my bones... etc Or are you suggesting that verbal punishment is worse, if that is so perhaps you should consider the possible harm the rules are doing to its members. Being so aware as you seem to be how dangerous and harmful words can be perhaps one needs to be very reluctant to use them or the powers some have thats attached to them. Yes there is such a thing as verbal abuse. But call me what you like, I think fighting physically is the last resort, though it depends on ones brain capacity just on how quickly a physical fight develops.

 

It is good everyone has a different view or life would be boring. I do totally disagree with you Mario but, that is all good and to be expected and, as someone who deals with the written abuse regularly, and who has seen the results of written abuse to people who have killed themselves because of it, I stand by my saying that words can be more dangerous.

As for women fighting, I fight and am also very feminine but that is my choice and in no way would I expect you to agree :)

 

Yngve Alexandersson

1 Year Ago

Who said woman can`t throw a punsh......
Norwegian female boxer Cecilia Brækhus, world champion four times. (WBA, WBC, WBO and WPBF)

http://youtu.be/zl5mMH8-Qi4


Y.Alexandersson

 

Roseann Caputo

1 Year Ago

Mike - So, we're allowed to do it as exercise, but not allowed to practice it in the ring? And if we're doing it for self-defense, how do we know we have it correct? I disagree with the comparrison to bear-baiting, cock fighting and the bullring. The animals do not *choose* to engage in those fights. Human beings have the ability to choose. I despise all three of those things and dog fighting. Culturally speaking a number of asian cultures developed martial arts and their styles and women have been very much involved with it for a long time, longer than women in boxing. They also compete. Are you saying because it offends some male's sensibilities they should not be allowed to compete?

Here are two women who are very much women that would seriously disagree:

Five years undefeated world martial arts champion in weapons and forms, Cynthia Rothrock: http://www.cynthiarothrock.org/

And classical pianist and five time US National Tae Kwon Do champion, traditional and creative forms, Elaine Kwon: http://www.elainekwon.com/index.html

FYI - I'm not a huge fan of boxing, but what people choose to do to themselves is their business. I've been a fan of martial arts most of my life. I admire the women who compete and do as well as the men.

 

Stephen King

1 Year Ago

If they so choose I think it's ok, as long as I don't get beat up by a girl. :-(

 

Mike Jeffries

1 Year Ago

Rosanne, Jeffrey asked for our thoughts on this subject and I stated mine. I have never said that they shouldn't be allowed to compete merely stated what I think of the competitions as a spectator sport. I am no shrinking violet who has led a sheltered life by any means but I do find the gladiatorial nature of these contests distasteful but would defend the right of women to take part in them if they so wished.

 

Paul Cowan

1 Year Ago

The worst aspect is the crowd that thinks it is entertaining to watch people try to injure each other. It's really disgusting watching them howling with excitement as two people seek to cause each other brain injury (which is the highest achievement in boxing, they call it a KO).

Roseann, I'm not sure how you consider women fighting each other as being "competing and doing as well as men". Anyone can fight - well or badly - and if women could do as well as men at fighting I guess they would be in the same ring fighting each other for world championship crowns.

 

Roseann Caputo

1 Year Ago

Mike - I would hope you're not a shrinking violet. LOL I have no problem with people finding them distasteful and thank you for being willing to defend a person's right to do it. :-)

Paul - Women are doing as well as men. Why they don't allow them to compete against each other is not something I've ever heard discussed.

 

Paul Cowan

1 Year Ago

Fairly obvious, I would have thought. But I do like to regale people with the blindingly obvious from time to time, it's amazing how many people are so blinded by it that they don't see it.

I'm not sure what the criteria are for "doing as well as men" in this context.

 

Roseann Caputo

1 Year Ago

You mean the basic difference in body configuration? Upper body strength of the male vs. the female? Cause I've seen some women kick the crap out of men roughly around the same size as each other.

Doing as well as men meaning they are fighting as well as men do.

 

Yngve Alexandersson

1 Year Ago

@ Paul and Rosann,
As an former martial artist, in my opinion I can say you both have some truth in what you are saying. Lets strip it down a little. If you have (theoretical) one male and one female, with the same size, weight, and skills. the man would most likely win because of his muscle wolume and his natural testoserone. There are also other natural body chemicals that will effect the result of the fight e.g adrenalin. Wich can benifit anyone in a fight or situation.
So..... in real life, regardless of gender it works like this; Technic and speed beats big muscles and strength in most of the times. But if you have all of it, speed, technis, strength and power you have the best oppertunitys to win a fight.
A male can normaly get more strength and physical benefits than a woman so he will always have the best chances. So if a woman fights a man about the same size, she needs more speed and technic to take him out. And the same goes for a man with less strengt / size than a woman.
For that reason, In proffesional fighting (any style), you seperate woman and men and also have weight classes.
Out on the street you can not say that; "hey! you are not in my weight class or we do not have the same genders" that can be a problem for anyone if you not have the right skills.

Y.ALexandersson

 

Roseann Caputo

1 Year Ago

Yngve - Thank you for the clarification. RE: the reference to out on the street. Exactly. And that's where I watched a woman wipe the floor with a man. There was no referee, no bell, no whistle. He started it, she finished it.

 

Jason Christopher

1 Year Ago

We always knew you had a bad temper Roseann!! Man Beater!! I expect u videoed ur victory to you tube... ok whats the link? LOL ok yeh i am joshing :-))

apparently.... a female soldier has just given birth on the front line in Helmund, Afghanistan.... she didnt realise she was pregnant! Doctors have been rushed to assist the female gunner who was 5 weeks premature.... Dedication. And totally crazy. what next. ... i should not have said that...

 

Roseann Caputo

1 Year Ago

LOL Jason. Although I was one of two other women present, it most definitely was not me. This is one case where I would have lost badly.

 

Yngve Alexandersson

1 Year Ago

That is great Rosann ! I have seen it my self so I have no problem belive in you ;-)
On the street, always expect the unexpected....

YA

 

Roseann Caputo

1 Year Ago

Yngve - and let's just say some of the other males who heard what that guy was saying, afterward felt the need to apologize on behalf of males because he was actually that crude. He got what he deserved.

 

Yngve Alexandersson

1 Year Ago

Yes he propably did ;=) Take care

YA

 

This discussion is closed.